Garlic Pull Apart
Bagel in Newmarket
Scored deep, stuffed with garlic butter and whipped cream cheese, finished with everything seasoning and fresh herbs. Served warm at Pinochio Newmarket — 16850 Yonge St #107.
The Newmarket store is at 16850 Yonge St, Unit 107, on Yonge just south of Upper Canada Mall. For most of York Region north of Aurora, this is the closest place to get the Garlic Pull Apart Bagel, and it is the one people drive to rather than stumble across.
Pinochio Newmarket
16850 Yonge St #107Newmarket, Ontario L3Y 5L8
+1 905 629 0004
Yonge Street is the only direction you need to remember. We are on the Yonge corridor a short way south of Upper Canada Mall, in a unit-numbered plaza with parking on site — Unit 107. If you are coming out of the mall, it is a couple of minutes down Yonge. From Highway 404, come across on Davis Drive or Mulock and turn onto Yonge. Because Yonge runs the full length of the region, this store also catches people driving down from Bradford and up from Aurora, which is exactly why it exists. Parking is off-street and free, so this is one of the low-friction stops — you are not paying for the privilege of picking up a bagel. For anyone north of Aurora, this is also the end of the line for the viral bagel: the next closest Pinochio is a drive south into Vaughan.
Busiest Hours at
Our Newmarket Store
Newmarket runs quieter in the afternoon and busier from dinner onward, with the heaviest traffic on Friday and Saturday nights when it is one of the few things still open late on this stretch of Yonge. Being a drive-to store rather than a walk-past one, most of the orders here are deliberate — people came for something specific rather than noticing us on the way past. That late window is also when the day's last bake tends to go, so if you are driving in from out of town, a quick call to +1 905 629 0004 first will save you the trip.
$6.99, Scored Deep,
Served Warm
The bagel is cut most of the way through into wedges, piped full of whipped cream cheese along every score, brushed in garlic butter and baked until the edges crisp. You pull it apart with your hands rather than slicing it. Everything seasoning and fresh herbs on top. Baked in-store here in Newmarket, in daily batches — which is why it can sell out late on a busy night.
Full detail, the story behind the format, and the eight most-asked questions are on the main garlic pull apart bagel page. Nearby: garlic pull apart bagel in Hamilton · garlic pull apart bagel in Waterloo.